Magicianly

SMS & WhatsApp

Klaviyo vs Attentive vs Postscript: Which SMS Platform Should a Shopify Brand Use?

Quick answer: If you already run email on Klaviyo, start with Klaviyo SMS. You get one profile, one set of segments and published per-message prices with carrier fees included. Postscript is a Shopify-first SMS platform with public, pay-after-you-send pricing, built mainly around the US and Canada. Attentive is a sales-led, SMS-first platform with custom pricing and contracts, most worth evaluating when SMS is the center of your program and you have the scale for it.

By Emiel Dingemans, Founder of Magicianly

Updated November 2026. Competitor information was last reviewed in November 2026.

Disclosure: we're an official Klaviyo partner and we manage Klaviyo accounts for a living, so we're not neutral. We've stuck to what each vendor publishes itself, and we'll tell you where Attentive or Postscript is the better fit.

What's the Difference Between Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript?

Klaviyo is an email and SMS platform in one. Postscript and Attentive started as SMS platforms. That one difference drives most of the rest.

  • Klaviyo: a full email platform with SMS, MMS, RCS and WhatsApp on the same customer profiles. Mobile messaging is billed as a separate monthly plan on top of your email plan.
  • Postscript: an SMS platform built first for Shopify, with SMS, MMS and RCS. Email is rolling out to brands in phases. Pricing is public: a plan fee or monthly minimum, per-message rates and carrier fees on their own line.
  • Attentive: an SMS-first platform that has grown into SMS, MMS, RCS, email and push. There are no public rates. Pricing is tailored per brand, usually with a contract.

Klaviyo vs Attentive vs Postscript at a Glance

Here's how the three compare on what they publish themselves.

KlaviyoPostscriptAttentive
Public SMS pricesYes, carrier fees includedYes for the US and Canada, carrier fees addedNo, custom pricing
How you payPrepaid monthly plan, unused spend doesn't roll overPay after you send, plan fee or $49 monthly minimumInvoiced, often with a minimum commit
ContractMonthly plansOptionalCommon
Email in the same platformYes, it's the core productRolling out in phasesYes
WhatsAppYesNot listed on its pricing pageNot listed on its pricing page
Inbound texts billedNot stated on the pages we checkedSome carriers charge inbound feesYes, incoming and outgoing
Quiet hoursSettings documented for flowsHolds campaigns and automationsCampaigns are not held

How Much Does SMS Cost on Klaviyo Compared to Attentive or Postscript?

At published list prices for US texts, Klaviyo's SMS plan comes out cheaper than Postscript's at 10,000 and at 100,000 texts a month. Attentive doesn't publish prices, so you can only compare it with a quote.

Klaviyo sells mobile messaging as a monthly plan you buy upfront. Carrier fees are included in the rate, and bigger plans get a lower rate per message. Here's what the public calculator on Klaviyo's pricing page shows for 1-segment texts:

Texts per monthUS (toll-free number)UK
1,000$15$70
10,000$125$575
50,000$575$2,660
100,000$1,115$5,250

At 100,000 US texts, that's 1.115 cents per text. Unused plan spend doesn't roll over to the next month. We checked every price in this article on November 16, 2026.

Postscript publishes its US and Canada rates on Postscript's pricing page. You pay after you send, and carrier fees are passed through on their own line.

Postscript planPlan feePer SMSPer MMS
Starter$0 a month, $49 monthly minimum$0.009$0.045
Growth$100 a month$0.008$0.03
Professional$500 a month$0.007$0.024
EnterpriseCustomCustomCustom

Postscript lists an average US carrier fee of $0.00435 per SMS. Add that, and here's what the list prices work out to for 1-segment US texts:

US texts per monthKlaviyoPostscript StarterPostscript GrowthPostscript Professional
10,000$125$133.50$223.50$613.50
100,000$1,115$1,335$1,335$1,635

That's our arithmetic from public list prices, not a quote. Carrier fees vary by carrier, and both vendors can offer different rates on a contract.

Two things the table doesn't show. Klaviyo's SMS plan sits on top of an email plan you'd pay for anyway. Postscript is SMS first, so most brands still pay a separate email platform next to it. And because Klaviyo is prepaid, a plan you don't use up still costs the full amount, while Postscript bills what you actually sent.

Attentive says on Attentive's pricing page that pricing is tailored to your message volume, subscriber list size, number of channels and the AI products you choose. Its help center names the parts of an invoice: per-message rates, carrier fees, a base fee, a list management fee, a short code fee and possible charges to meet a minimum commit. Ask for every one of those in writing when you get a quote.

How Much Does Postscript Cost?

Postscript costs a plan fee plus per-message rates plus carrier fees. Starter has no plan fee but a $49 monthly minimum and charges $0.009 per US SMS. Growth is $100 a month at $0.008 per SMS. Professional is $500 a month at $0.007 per SMS. Enterprise is custom.

A few more numbers from Postscript's own pages:

  • International texts: $0.25 per SMS outside the US and Canada on Starter, Growth and Professional.
  • UK: you need a UK 10-digit long code, which costs $1.15 a month.
  • Short code: a dedicated short code is $750 a month, passed through from the carriers.
  • Free trial: a $100 credit for your first 30 days, for message and carrier fees.
  • No profile fees and no required contract.
  • AI Plan: $699 a month, plus per-message rates of $0.003 to $0.30 depending on the product and message type.

Which SMS Platform Is Best for UK and EU Brands?

For most UK and EU brands, Klaviyo or Attentive. Postscript's public pricing and documentation are built mainly around the US and Canada.

Klaviyo lists the countries where you can collect SMS consent and send: the US, Canada and Mexico, Australia and New Zealand, and in Europe the UK, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and Switzerland. In the UK and most of those European countries, you send from a free branded sender ID with your brand name. Belgium and Hungary are the exceptions: a long code is the only sending number there, and that needs a paid SMS plan. UK texts cost more than US texts, and MMS isn't available in the UK.

Postscript documents sending to the UK (with that $1.15 long code) and Australia, at $0.25 per international SMS. We didn't find a full list of sending countries in its help center. Its default double opt-in country list doesn't include the Netherlands, so check with Postscript before you sign if you sell in mainland Europe.

Attentive lists text messaging in the UK, Ireland, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Sweden and Norway, among others. Several other countries were marked as early access in its help center, so confirm the status of your countries in the quote.

Do You Need a Separate SMS Platform If You Already Use Klaviyo?

Usually not. If your email runs on Klaviyo, Klaviyo SMS uses the same profiles, the same segments and the same flow data. That's the biggest practical difference, and it doesn't show up in a price table.

Here's why it matters in daily work:

  • One customer, one profile. You see email and SMS behavior in one place and build one segment for both channels.
  • One set of exclusions. Every SMS campaign we send excludes recent buyers, usually Buyers Last 3 Days. That segment already exists in Klaviyo. With a separate SMS platform, you have to keep that data in sync between two tools.
  • One place to check cost against revenue. SMS has paid media economics. Every text costs money, so someone has to put the cost of each send next to what it made.

We go deeper on the Klaviyo side in our guide to Klaviyo SMS marketing, and on the numbers in how much SMS marketing costs.

When Does Attentive Make Sense?

Attentive is worth evaluating when SMS is the center of your program, not a supporting channel, and the brand has the scale for a sales-led platform.

It fits when:

  • SMS is a top revenue channel and you want a platform built around it
  • you want a dedicated customer success manager and onboarding support
  • your team is ready to negotiate a contract with a minimum commit

Go in with your eyes open on the contract. Attentive offers lower rates in exchange for a recurring minimum spend. If you send less than the commit, the rest is still invoiced. Its public terms say fees are non-cancellable and non-refundable. Read the order form before you sign, and note the end date.

We also cover Attentive briefly in our roundup of Klaviyo alternatives.

When Does Postscript Make Sense?

Postscript makes sense for a Shopify brand that sells mainly in the US and Canada, wants SMS as a serious channel, and prefers public prices and no required contract.

It fits when:

  • your SMS subscribers are almost all in the US and Canada
  • you want to pay after you send instead of buying a plan upfront
  • you're fine running email on a different platform for now

If most of your customers are in Europe, Postscript's $0.25 international rate and its US-first documentation make it a harder fit.

How Do Double Opt-In and Quiet Hours Differ?

All three use double opt-in for SMS, but they handle quiet hours differently. Check this before you schedule your first campaign.

Double opt-in. Klaviyo says you should always use double opt-in for SMS lists, and skips the confirmation text automatically on branded sender IDs, because those can't receive replies. Postscript requires double opt-in. Attentive says its standard sign-up flows use double opt-in. We explain the email side of that decision in single vs double opt-in.

Quiet hours. Postscript holds campaigns and automations until waking hours in the subscriber's time zone. Attentive holds journey messages if you set it up that way, but scheduled campaigns still send at the time you chose. Klaviyo's quiet hours settings are documented for flows. Whatever you use, schedule SMS campaigns inside legal sending hours for the recipient's location yourself.

What About AI Features?

All three sell AI tools, and all three publish big performance claims for them. Treat those numbers as marketing until you see them in your own account.

  • Klaviyo: Composer, an AI marketing agent, and Customer Agent, which can answer customers over SMS.
  • Postscript: an AI Plan at $699 a month plus per-message rates, including Shopper and Infinity Testing.
  • Attentive: AI Pro and AI Grow as add-ons, and AI Journeys, priced per click.

We don't pick an SMS platform on AI features. Pick it on fit, data and real cost, then test the AI on a small part of your program.

How Do You Choose Between Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript?

Start with two questions: where does your email live, and how central is SMS to your revenue? Most brands can decide from there.

Your situationStart with
Email runs on Klaviyo and SMS supports itKlaviyo SMS
You sell in the UK or the EUKlaviyo, or Attentive if SMS is your main channel
US-focused Shopify brand that wants SMS-first features and no contractPostscript
SMS is your center of gravity and you have the scale for a sales-led contractAttentive

Then get the real numbers. Ask each vendor for your rate per segment, your countries, carrier fees, monthly minimums, contract length and what happens to unused spend.

So Which SMS Platform Should You Use?

For most Shopify brands that already use Klaviyo for email, Klaviyo SMS is the simplest place to start, and on public US list prices it's cheaper than Postscript. Postscript is a strong SMS-first option for US-focused brands that want public pricing and no contract. Attentive fits brands where SMS is the main channel and a sales-led contract makes sense.

Want help setting up SMS that pays for itself? That's what our SMS marketing service does.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Klaviyo SMS cheaper than Postscript?

On public list prices for US texts, yes at 10,000 and 100,000 texts a month, once you add Postscript's plan fee and average carrier fees. Klaviyo's plan is prepaid and doesn't roll over, while Postscript bills what you send, so compare it with your real volume.

How much does Attentive cost?

Attentive doesn't publish prices. It quotes based on your message volume, list size, channels and AI products, and invoices can include a base fee, a list management fee, a short code fee, carrier fees and a minimum commit. Ask for all of them in writing.

How much does Postscript cost per text?

On its public US and Canada rates, $0.009 per SMS on Starter, $0.008 on Growth and $0.007 on Professional, plus carrier fees and the plan fee or $49 monthly minimum. Texts outside the US and Canada cost $0.25 each on those plans.

Do I need Attentive or Postscript if I already use Klaviyo?

Usually not. Klaviyo SMS uses the same profiles, segments and exclusions as your email. A separate SMS platform makes the most sense when SMS is your main channel or you need something Klaviyo doesn't offer.

Which SMS platform is best for UK and European brands?

Klaviyo and Attentive both list a long set of European countries, including the UK and the Netherlands. Postscript documents UK and Australian sending at $0.25 per international text, but its pricing and documentation focus on the US and Canada.

Can I leave Attentive before my contract ends?

Check your order form. Attentive's public terms say fees are non-cancellable and non-refundable, and minimum commits are invoiced even if you send less. Plan a switch around the end of your contract term.

Want Us to Build and Manage This for You?

Related Reading