Magicianly

List Growth

Single vs Double Opt-In: Which Should Your Ecommerce Brand Use?

Quick answer: Double opt-in means a new subscriber has to confirm their signup, usually by clicking a link in a confirmation email, before they're added to your list. Single opt-in adds them right away. For ecommerce email, we use single opt-in by default, because the extra step costs you real subscribers. We switch to double opt-in only temporarily, when bot signups push your bounce rate up. For SMS, we keep double opt-in on, as Klaviyo recommends.

Most brands never chose their opt-in setting.

Klaviyo chose it for them.

New email lists in Klaviyo inherit your account's default opt-in setting, and that default is double opt-in unless someone changed it. So plenty of stores are running a confirmation step they never decided on, and losing signups because of it.

Here's how we think about it, and what we set up for the brands we work with.

By Emiel Dingemans, Founder of Magicianly

Updated

What Is Double Opt-In?

Double opt-in is a signup process where a new subscriber has to confirm their subscription before they're added to your list. They fill in your form, get a confirmation email or text, and only join the list after they confirm.

Single opt-in skips that second step. Someone submits the form and they're subscribed.

In Klaviyo, the setting lives on the list. If a list uses double opt-in, only people who confirm get added, and only they get queued for your welcome series.

What Is the Difference Between Single and Double Opt-In?

The difference is one extra step, and that step changes both list size and list quality.

Single opt-inDouble opt-in
What the subscriber doesSubmits the formSubmits the form, then confirms in an email or text
When they join the listImmediatelyOnly after confirming
When the welcome flow startsRight after signupOnly after confirmation
List growthHigherLower, because some people never confirm
Protection against fake and mistyped signupsLowHigh
Our default for emailYesOnly temporarily, during bot signups
Our default for SMSNoYes

Is Double Opt-In Better for Email Marketing?

Not for most ecommerce brands. Double opt-in gives you a cleaner list, but it asks people to do too much to subscribe, and that hurts list growth.

Think about the moment. Someone wants your welcome offer. They type their email. Now they have to leave your site, open their inbox, find your email (maybe in Promotions, maybe in spam) and click again.

Some will. A lot won't.

Those are real people who wanted to hear from you, and they never make it onto your list. That's why we run single opt-in for email by default.

The usual argument for double opt-in is deliverability. Klaviyo makes that case in its own documentation: inbox providers like Google and Yahoo watch how people engage with your email, and invalid or uninterested addresses hurt you. Fair point. But you can protect list quality without taxing every real subscriber:

  • send campaigns to engaged segments, not your whole list
  • suppress hard bounces
  • sunset profiles that stopped engaging
  • keep signup sources clean (no purchased lists, and be careful with giveaways)

Our email deliverability checklist covers the full version.

When Should You Use Double Opt-In?

Use double opt-in for email when bots are flooding your forms and your bounce rate goes up because of it. That's the one situation where we switch it on, and we treat it as temporary.

Bot signups usually show up as a jump in new subscribers that doesn't match your traffic, addresses that look random, and welcome emails bouncing far more than usual. Every fake address gets your welcome flow, bounces, and drags down your sender reputation.

Double opt-in stops that, because a bot can't confirm. Once the attack is over and the source is fixed, we switch the list back to single opt-in.

There's one more case: if your legal advisor requires double opt-in for a market you sell into, follow that advice.

Should You Use Double Opt-In for SMS?

Yes. For SMS we keep double opt-in on. Klaviyo says you should always use double opt-in for SMS lists, because carriers often require it, particularly for abandoned cart texts in the US and Canada.

A few Klaviyo details worth knowing:

  • New SMS lists, and lists with "SMS" in the name, start on double opt-in automatically.
  • SMS keywords have their own opt-in setting, which overrides the list's setting.
  • Branded sender IDs can't receive replies, so Klaviyo skips the confirmation text automatically in countries where you use one.
  • On a paid SMS plan, Smart Opt-in lets people confirm inside the signup form with a one-time code. Klaviyo requires that code even if the list is single opt-in.

So the split is simple: single opt-in for email, double opt-in for SMS. More on running texts in our Klaviyo SMS guide.

How Do You Turn Off Double Opt-In in Klaviyo?

You change it per list. Open the list, go to Settings > Consent, select Single opt-in under Opt-in process and save.

Step by step:

  1. Go to Audience > Lists & segments and open your main email list.
  2. Click Settings.
  3. Click Consent.
  4. Under Opt-in process, select Single opt-in.
  5. Click Save.

Then check three things:

  • Every list your forms feed. Changing the account default does not update existing lists.
  • Your welcome flow. New subscribers on a single opt-in list are added right away, so the welcome flow fires immediately. Test a signup yourself.
  • Third-party forms. If your signup tool already sends its own confirmation, Klaviyo suggests turning off double opt-in on the Klaviyo list so people don't get two confirmation messages.

List imports don't trigger double opt-in either way. For the full walkthrough, see Klaviyo's guide to the double opt-in process.

What Happens to People Who Never Confirm?

They're not subscribed. With double opt-in on a Klaviyo sign-up form, a profile can still be created with the details from the form, and Klaviyo can track their site activity, but they haven't joined the list and haven't given marketing consent.

That's the hidden cost. These people were interested enough to type their email, and you can't send them marketing.

If you run double opt-in, compare your form submissions with the number of people actually added to the list. The gap is what the confirmation step costs you.

Does Double Opt-In Hurt Your Signup Rate?

It doesn't change how many people submit your form. It lowers how many of those submits become subscribers. Your popup can convert well and your list can still grow slowly, because part of every day's signups never confirm.

That matters because the form is where list growth starts. For most brands, we want to see signup rates in the 6 to 12% range. If you're putting work into getting there, don't lose part of it at a confirmation step you don't need. Our guide to popup signup rates shows how to get there.

What If Your Popup Gives a Discount Code?

With single opt-in, show the code on screen right after signup. With double opt-in, send it in the first welcome email after confirmation. If you show it on screen, people can take the code and never confirm.

Either way, the welcome flow does the real work after signup. Here's how we build a Klaviyo welcome flow.

What Are the Most Common Double Opt-In Mistakes?

The biggest one is running double opt-in by accident, because it's Klaviyo's account default and nobody checked. The others we see:

  • leaving it on for months after a bot attack ended
  • switching SMS to single opt-in to grow faster
  • changing the account default and assuming existing lists changed too
  • never testing the confirmation email, so nobody notices when it stops arriving
  • treating double opt-in as a substitute for list hygiene

A confirmed subscriber can still go cold. Keep cleaning your list in Klaviyo either way.

So Should You Use Single or Double Opt-In?

For email, single opt-in. You keep every real subscriber, and you protect quality with engaged segments, bounce suppression and sunsetting.

Switch to double opt-in only while bots are hitting your forms and pushing your bounce rate up. Then switch back.

For SMS, double opt-in. Always.

Want forms that grow a list worth having? That's what our sign-up forms service is for.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does double opt-in mean?

Double opt-in means a new subscriber confirms their signup, usually by clicking a link in a confirmation email or replying to a text, before they're added to your list. Single opt-in adds them as soon as they submit the form.

Is double opt-in required by law?

Not everywhere. Requirements differ by country and by channel, so check with your legal advisor for the markets you sell into. For SMS, Klaviyo recommends always using double opt-in because carriers often require it.

Is double opt-in on by default in Klaviyo?

Usually, yes. New email lists inherit your account's default opt-in setting, which is double opt-in unless someone changed it. New SMS lists always start on double opt-in.

Does double opt-in improve deliverability?

It keeps fake and mistyped addresses off your list, which helps. But engaged segments, bounce suppression and sunsetting also protect deliverability, without losing real subscribers at a confirmation step.

Can I switch from double to single opt-in later?

Yes. In Klaviyo you change it per list under Settings > Consent. The new setting applies to people who subscribe after the change.

Should I use double opt-in for SMS?

Yes. Klaviyo recommends double opt-in for SMS lists because carriers often require it, especially for abandoned cart texts in the US and Canada.

Want Us to Build and Manage This for You?

Related Reading