Email Automations
Review Request Emails: When to Send Them and How to Get More Reviews
Quick answer: Send a review request email once the customer has had enough time to actually use the product, not a fixed number of days after the order. Work it out from delivery time plus the time it takes to judge the product, and don't wait so long that the excitement fades. Always send a reminder. We recommend offering a free gift in that reminder, for any honest review, not just positive ones.
Most review request emails go out on day 7 because that's what the template said.
For some products that's fine. For others, the package hasn't arrived yet, or the customer has used it once and has no real opinion.
Timing decides whether you get a thoughtful review, a rushed one, or nothing at all.
Here's how we time review requests, what goes in them, and why the reminder matters as much as the first email.
By Emiel Dingemans, Founder of Magicianly
Updated
What Is a Review Request Email?
A review request email asks a recent customer to rate and review the product they bought. It usually sits in your post-purchase flow, triggered by fulfillment or delivery, and links straight to the review form for that product.
Reviews do two jobs. They give new visitors social proof on your product pages. And they tell you what customers really think of the product.
When Should You Send a Review Request Email?
Send it when the customer has had enough time to judge the product, but before the enthusiasm fades. There's no universal delay. It depends on two things: how long shipping takes and how long it takes to judge the product.
Review request timing = time to deliver + time to judge the product
Then check one thing: will the customer still be excited at that point? If the gap gets long, momentum fades, and so does your chance of a review.
| Product type | What the customer needs to judge it | When we'd ask |
|---|---|---|
| Food, coffee, candles | One or two uses | Soon after delivery |
| Apparel and shoes | Fit, a few wears, a first wash | After they've worn it a few times |
| Skincare and supplements | Results that take weeks | After a few weeks of regular use |
| Equipment and tech | Setup plus repeated use | After real use, not right after unboxing |
If your product takes months to show its full effect, don't wait months. Ask about the experience so far, while they still remember buying it.
Got a catalog with very different products? Then one delay for everything is the wrong setup. Split the timing by product type or collection.
Should You Time Review Requests From Fulfillment or Delivery?
From delivery, whenever you can. Fulfillment only tells you the package left the warehouse. With shipping delays, a delay based on fulfillment can land before the product even arrives.
Klaviyo Reviews on Shopify can base timing on the delivery date using shipment tracking, with a separate fallback delay after fulfillment for orders without a delivery date. Neither delay can be longer than 60 days. WooCommerce stores can only time from fulfillment. Klaviyo covers the settings in its guide to adjusting review request timing.
Using a third-party review app with a Klaviyo flow? Klaviyo's advice is to trigger on Fulfilled Order and set a delay longer than your average delivery time. Then add your time to judge on top.
Should You Send a Review Reminder?
Yes, always. Plenty of customers mean to leave a review and simply forget. The reminder catches them.
Give the first email some time, then send one reminder to everyone who hasn't left a review yet.
That reminder is where we recommend offering a free gift.
Should You Offer an Incentive for Reviews?
We recommend it, in the reminder: a free gift for leaving a review. The gift has to be for any honest review, positive or negative, and the review should be marked as incentivized.
That's not just good manners. In the US, the FTC's rule on consumer reviews makes it illegal to give an incentive in exchange for, or conditioned on, a review that expresses a particular sentiment, positive or negative. You can read it in 16 CFR 465.4. A gift for a 5-star review is out. A gift for your honest review is the line. The FTC's guidance also says the review should disclose the incentive.
Klaviyo Reviews supports this. Its review request flow suggests incentives like a discount, free shipping or loyalty points, lets you mark reviews as incentivized, and says you must send the reward whatever the review says. A separate review follow-up flow, triggered when someone submits a review, delivers the reward.
Two more rules:
- Never offer anything for a Google review. Google's Maps content policy doesn't allow businesses to offer payment, discounts, free goods or services in exchange for any review. Keep incentives to product reviews on your own site, and check the rules of your review platform.
- Ask everyone, not just happy customers. Picking only the customers you expect to leave good reviews skews the picture, and the FTC's guidance warns against it.
What Should a Review Request Email Say?
Keep it short. One product, one ask, one button. Say what they bought, ask how it's going, and make the review form one click away.
What we include:
- the product image and name, so they know exactly what you mean
- one line asking how it's going so far
- a star rating or a button that opens the review form for that product
- a line saying honest reviews help other customers decide
- a way to get help if something went wrong
Here's a simple first email:
Subject: How's your [product name] so far? You've had your [product name] for a little while now. How's it going? Your honest review helps other customers decide if it's right for them. [Leave a review] Something not right? Just reply to this email and we'll sort it out.
And the reminder:
Subject: Got a minute for a quick review? We'd love to hear what you think of your [product name]. Leave an honest review, good or bad, and we'll send you a free gift as a thank you. [Leave a review]
The support line matters. Someone with a problem should reach your team before they reach the review form.
Which Tools Can Send Review Request Emails?
Most Shopify review apps send review requests automatically, and many connect to Klaviyo.
- Klaviyo Reviews: built into Klaviyo. A review request flow triggered by the Ready to review event, plus a follow-up flow triggered by a submitted review. Reviews left through the flow get a Verified buyer badge.
- Judge.me: a Shopify reviews app with automated review requests and a free plan.
- Okendo: a Shopify reviews platform with a Klaviyo integration, so review events can trigger your Klaviyo flows.
- Yotpo: automates review requests by email and SMS, triggered by order data.
Whichever you use, make sure the review request doesn't collide with your other post-purchase emails.
Where Does the Review Request Fit in Your Post-Purchase Flow?
After the customer has the product and has used it. Before that, your post-purchase emails have other jobs: confirming the order, setting expectations and helping them get value from the product.
A typical order:
- Order confirmation email
- Shipping and delivery updates
- How to use the product
- Review request
- Review reminder
- The next logical product
Two settings to check in Klaviyo. First, turn Smart Sending off on the review request and the reminder, so a campaign the day before doesn't skip them. Second, make sure people who already left a review, or whose order was refunded or canceled, don't get the reminder.
We cover the full sequence in our post-purchase email sequence guide.
What Are the Most Common Review Request Mistakes?
The most common one is a single fixed delay for every product in the catalog. The others we see:
- timing from fulfillment when the package hasn't arrived yet
- no reminder
- a reward only for positive reviews
- any incentive for Google reviews
- an upsell in the same email, so neither ask lands
- review requests for refunded or canceled orders
So When Should You Send a Review Request Email?
When the customer can judge the product, and while they still care. Time it from delivery, add the time it takes to judge the product, and send one reminder with a free gift for any honest review. Keep incentives away from Google.
Want us to build your post-purchase and review flows? That's what our email automations service does.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long after purchase should you send a review request email?
There's no single number. Add the delivery time to the time a customer needs to judge the product. A snack can be reviewed soon after delivery. Skincare may need weeks of use.
Should I send a reminder for a review request?
Yes. Many customers mean to leave a review and forget. Send one reminder to people who haven't reviewed yet.
Can I offer a discount or free gift for a review?
Yes, for product reviews on your own site, as long as the reward is for any honest review and not tied to a positive rating, and the review is marked as incentivized. Check your review platform's rules first.
Can I offer an incentive for Google reviews?
No. Google's policy doesn't allow businesses to offer payment, discounts, free goods or services in exchange for a review.
Should review requests come from Klaviyo or from my review app?
Either works. Klaviyo Reviews has its own review request flow, and Klaviyo can also send review requests for a third-party review app through a flow.
Should a review request email include an upsell?
We keep it to one ask. Save the cross-sell for a separate email later in the post-purchase flow.
Want Us to Build and Manage This for You?
Related Reading
Email Automations
Post-Purchase Email Sequence: How to Drive the Second PurchaseA good post-purchase sequence should do more than say thanks. Here is the email-by-email framework we use to improve the customer experience and create the next purchase.
Read NowEmail Automations
Post-Purchase Emails: What to Send After the First OrderThe purchase is not the finish line. A strong post-purchase email strategy reduces uncertainty, improves the experience and creates the path toward order number two.
Read NowEmail Automations
How to Build a High-Converting Ecommerce Post-Purchase FlowA practical post-purchase flow framework covering timing, Klaviyo setup, first-time vs returning customers, education, cross-sell and repeat purchase.
Read NowEmail Automations
Order Confirmation Email: What to Include, a Template and ExamplesWhat your order confirmation email should include, a template you can copy, examples by brand type, and how to set it up in Shopify or Klaviyo.
Read Now
